Contributed by Stephen Wickman, St. Thomas Episcopal, McLean
I recently had the honor of representing my church at the 232nd Annual Convention of The Episcopal Diocese of Virginia, which can be a bit mind-numbing. But the keynote address from The Very Rev’d Ian S. Markham, Ph.D., Dean and President of Virginia Theological Seminary came just in time for Thanksgiving.
Among other fun things, Markam warned against simplistic or political misreadings of scripture and emphasized that reading scripture requires honest reflection, prayer, and a willingness to stay in conversation with people who hold different views. (Well, our diocese has more than a little bit of unpleasant history here.)
Here’s my favorite bits (You can scroll through the Friday video to hear it here, starting at about 1 hour 40 minutes in: 232nd Annual Convention Recap: “Read the Book. Tell the Story.” – The Episcopal Diocese of Virginia)
“[T]he part of Christianity I find hardest, it’s living the simplest of all the commandments. These are the commandments that actually are not difficult to understand. They’re sort of pretty obvious. So, Matthew chapter 6, Jesus says, ‘Do not worry about tomorrow.’ That passage starts with, ‘Therefore I tell you, do not worry about your life, what you will eat, or what you will drink or about your body, what you will wear.’
Do you know I violate that commandment every single day of my life? I mean, and sometimes at a very trivial level, you know, I’m going out to a party with friends, and I stand in my wardrobe, and I worry about what I’m going to wear. It is, and it’s one of those injunctions from Christ that most of us kind of disagree with. We think Jesus is really wrong. At the very least, Jesus is deeply impractical. And anyway, what’s wrong with it?
Now, of course, if you sit with the passage, it’s extraordinary. Jesus says, ‘Look, worry does not change one thing. In fact, what it does is it distracts you from the moment you’re in. It corrodes the gift that God’s giving you in that second and it is anticipating scenarios that are beyond your control. And the passage culminates with that seek ye first the kingdom of God and God’s righteousness and all these things will be added unto you. It basically says when you worry you don’t trust. And if you’re not trusting, you’re not grounded. You’re not living as if God really is….
Now, if I had more time and it was an entirely different lecture, I would tell you why the scale and size of God and this universe actually points to one of the strongest arguments for faith. It’s called the anthropic principle and it’s an entirely different talk. But it was necessary for us to emerge that the universe was this old and this big. Okay, just take it on authority. But disregarding that truth, when Jesus says don’t worry, Jesus really invites us to believe and trust in the God we worship….
One reason why I love the Episcopal church is we like to confess our sins all the time… I mean, it’s good because God’s always working with us. We’re a lump of clay, and I’m more lumpy than most…Okay, so you have that passage in Matthew 18. Peter came and said to him, ‘Lord, if another member of the church sins against me, how often should I forgive? As many as seven times.?’ Now, I’m kind of with Peter there. I think seven times is a big number to be honest. Uh, forgiving you once, I could handle that. Pretty cool. Forgiving twice, I’m slightly upset. Really? You circle around and do the same thing again. Forgiving three times is like, okay. Okay. I’m going to see my therapist. This ain’t healthy. I mean, okay. And then Jesus replies, ‘No, not seven times, but I tell you 77 times.’ See, being biblical is living with these texts.
So why? Well, Jesus says you got to do that because in the end, being human is rubbing along and injuring each other all the time. It helps considerably for me to understand this text when you’re one of six siblings….
When you’re trying to explain your faith to somebody who’s skeptical, start with prayer.
Start with the fact that if you’re a Christian, your sense of living in this world is you’re constantly aware that you are in a world intended and you’re in a world which is a result of love and you are surrounded by that love and you’re in conversation with that love. That’s what prayer is. And the reason why you start there rather than starting with, you know, why does God allow evil and suffering? Do dogs get to heaven? You know, all the stuff that gets thrown at you.
Start with that. And then at some point in the conversation when you’re talking about living life in the light of prayer, pivot very gently and say something like this:
‘Do you know what puzzles me? I do not understand people who believe that everything that is and everything we are just complicated bundles of atoms that emerge from nowhere and are going nowhere. That’s such a funny world view.’
Now what’s nice about that moment is suddenly your friend is actually facing the implications of their metaphysic. You know there are only two choices. You’re either going to be a theist and believe in a personal god or you’re going to be a materialist. That’s it right? Granted there are subsections over here, but that’s your choice. And agnosticism… but that’s a waste of time. Okay. [laughter]
So, you only have two choices. You’re either going to be a materialist, by which I mean you believe everything’s matter and there’s nothing other than matter. There’s no spirit, right? You know, so if you’re a materialist, why do people matter? If you’re materialist, how do you make sense of morality? If you’re materialist, where did truth come from? And how’s it possible that randomness can produce accounts of the world that make sense? That’s a C.S, Lewis argument. If you’re materialist, you know, in other words, it’s…
And anyway, nobody lives like a materialist. My atheist friends, they’re right up there for social justice. They’re not living materialism. They’re anonymous theists. All they’ve got to do is learn how to pray and they’ll be in a relationship with the source of the morality that shapes their lives. That’s the truth.
See, what happens when we have conversations is we invite our skeptical friends to list all the objections to faith. What are you imagining? You know, uh how can God be both timeless and active? Why does God allow evil and suffering? What happens to other religions? The church has been pretty nasty in the history of the world. Why should I trust it? Sure, bring them on.
But just occasionally pivot and say, ‘Yeah, but you’re asking these questions in a way that doesn’t really make sense. If you’re being true to your metaphysical materialism, you don’t really believe people are just complicated bundles of atoms that emerge from nowhere and are going nowhere. You think people matter. So why should they matter any more than a carrot? Carrots are important. I grant you….’
And finally, I did do the courtesy of reading Steven Wolf’s case for Christian nationalism.
I’m an old-fashioned liberal. Talk to people you disagree with however repugnant you might find them to be. Certainly, talk to those who are family and friends. Definitely, do so over Thanksgiving.
Stay in conversation.
Why? Because Jesus told us we have to forgive all those that drive us crazy. And however hard it is, and believe me, it’s hard, we do so because we read the words in the text. We are struggling to live that text. Thank you very much for listening.”
This blog post is the expressed opinion of its writer and does not necessarily reflect the views of Tysons Interfaith or its members.
Copyright 2026 © TYSONS INTERFAITH. All rights reserved.